• Sign Up! To view all forums and unlock additional cool features

    Welcome to the #1 Fiesta ST Forum and Fiesta ST community dedicated to Fiesta ST owners and enthusiasts. Register for an account, it's free and it's easy, so don't hesitate to join the Fiesta ST Forum today!


What is this part-throttle surge you speak of?

Trader history for Jason@dizzytuning (0)

Messages
402
Likes
901
Location
Rocky Point
#1
I wanted to start a new thread for this discussion, as to not derail any of my other threads.

I have had isolated reports of what I like to call a “part-throttle surge” on the Dizzy Tuning Fiesta Flash Tune. You can reproduce this surge by going into 3rd, 4th, 5th (or really any) gear, with the RPM around 2,000. If you then lay into it fairly aggressively, but only to about 60% throttle position, and hold the pedal there. You will experience a surging, regardless of the intake or exhaust modifications. Aftermarket intakes that are much noisier, will make the issue much more pronounced/audible. Testing with aftermarket actuators is coming soon, but I have confirmed it is NOT the actuator causing the surge.

I also want to state up front that my Flash Tune is not the only calibration that exhibits this behavior. I have confirmed that it is present in the Cobb OTS maps (v500, I have not yet tested the v504 for this phenomenon), as well as other Protuner maps. I will not go into much detail here, but have spoken with numerous customers using various other tunes, and they have noticed it as well. I do think the intensity of this surge may vary by tuner, but it is always still there (in my opinion, and I have seen datalogs).

So what causes this surge, and why has no one addressed it? This is something I have been working on over the past few months, and plan to implement in my upcoming Fiesta Flash Tune V2!

Let’s go into a little more detail, shall we. The ECU uses what is called a torque (or load) targeting strategy, rather than the old school boost targeting strategy. Torque targeting is fantastic because it allows your engine to run consistently in virtually all weather conditions. Some of you may notice that your boost values may be slightly lower in the winter, and higher in the summer. This is cause the colder denser air requires less boost to achieve the same torque values that it would have in the warmer months with higher boost levels. But the overall underlying issue (in my opinion) is the overly aggressive torque targeting tables, coupled with a VERY small turbo that spools almost instantaneously.

So if we think about the processes in slow motion, it would look something like this:

  • You press the accelerator pedal aggressively, while rolling at a constant rpm
  • The ECU uses the Throttle Requested Torque tables to lookup/determine what torque we want to achieve, based on current RPM and APP
    (The tables are aggressive, so they request a high torque value)
  • The throttle opens abruptly and the wastegate closes, spooling the turbo
  • You then overshoot your torque lookup target in the Throttle Requested Torque tables, due to the initial overly aggressive target
  • Now the ECU closes the throttle and reduces boost, via the wastegate
  • The process may repeat depending on the above conditions


So how can we fix this? We can modify the Throttle Requested Torque tables to target torque more appropriately based on turbo size and flow modifications on the vehicle. The result is smooth ETC (Electronic Throttle Control) operation that more closely matches APP (Accelerator Pedal Position). Stay tuned!
 


Attachments

Messages
188
Likes
83
Location
Baton Rouge
#2
Yeah, this is a thing. I have had this happen on most (all?) off the shelf tunes as well as a custom pro-tune. I've seen it on stock turbos, hybrid turbos, and big turbos. Most common on the stock and hybrids. When I noticed it once in the log on my personal car, I just requested my tuner to look at it...fixed on the next revision. It only seems to pop up at high throttle in certain gears at a specific RPM window. We have a really old thread somewhere talking about the saw-tooth throttle blade behavior before and how to improve or dampen it for "self" tuners, but we've never had a vendor address it before.

Thanks.
 


alexrex20

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,472
Likes
611
Location
Spring
#4
I can confirm that this happened on brand A's tune but doesn't on brand B. Great explanation Jason. I agree it's not a bad thing, albeit slightly annoying to the driver. My passengers never even noticed it and to be honest, I only really noticed it when I had the AP hooked up with boost level as a bar graph and I saw it bouncing up and down. It was almost imperceptible in the seat.
 


Messages
87
Likes
48
Location
Dripping Springs
#6
I can also say I have felt this phenomena. I thought perhaps I had a bad tank of gas, cleaned my MAF sensor, etc. Reassuring to see it's not an isolated incident on my side. TBT, it's not annoying, and only happens when say accelerating on a curvy back road where I don't want to give it the full beans, but still want to move quickly.

Jason- if you get this sorted, will you be offering a v2 update at a discount for those with the older tune?
 


OP
J
Messages
402
Likes
901
Location
Rocky Point
Thread Starter #7
I can also say I have felt this phenomena. I thought perhaps I had a bad tank of gas, cleaned my MAF sensor, etc. Reassuring to see it's not an isolated incident on my side. TBT, it's not annoying, and only happens when say accelerating on a curvy back road where I don't want to give it the full beans, but still want to move quickly.

Jason- if you get this sorted, will you be offering a v2 update at a discount for those with the older tune?
Absolutely. It will either be a small fee to update, or I will offer it at no charge (for existing customers).
 


CSM

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,528
Likes
1,621
Location
Cleveland, OH, USA
#9
I've got this on my V2 93 octane tune. Its pretty mild, but still there.

FWIW My car always did this even when I had the MP215 tune on there as well.
 


TyphoonFiST

9000 Post Club
Premium Account
Messages
11,495
Likes
7,986
Location
Rich-fizzield
#10
I can also say I have felt this phenomena. I thought perhaps I had a bad tank of gas, cleaned my MAF sensor, etc. Reassuring to see it's not an isolated incident on my side. TBT, it's not annoying, and only happens when say accelerating on a curvy back road where I don't want to give it the full beans, but still want to move quickly.

Jason- if you get this sorted, will you be offering a v2 update at a discount for those with the older tune?
I thought our cars were speed density? Or am I wrong? What was the fix for this issue? anyone solve it?
 


OP
J
Messages
402
Likes
901
Location
Rocky Point
Thread Starter #11
I thought our cars were speed density? Or am I wrong? What was the fix for this issue? anyone solve it?
Yes, they are SD based ecu’s, but still retain a maf sensor for airflow and intake temperature calculations.
My V2 Flash Tune addresses this issue, as it is tune-related.
 


TyphoonFiST

9000 Post Club
Premium Account
Messages
11,495
Likes
7,986
Location
Rich-fizzield
#12
Yes, they are SD based ecu’s, but still retain a maf sensor for airflow and intake temperature calculations.
My V2 Flash Tune addresses this issue, as it is tune-related.
I thought so....but I remember the MAF being in the intake tube also....just wanted to clarify for others! You're the best Jason! Now I wait with baited breath for my revision from you and your wizard hands!


Sent from my SM-N950U1 using Tapatalk
 


Similar threads



Top