Michigan (high no-fault rates), 40, good credit, clean record. I pay $960/year through USAA. $0 comprehensive, glass. Free towing. $500 collision. $200K and $400K limits of liability with $1,000,000. umbrella. Further, I have had unfortunately four claims in 22 months, one a total loss, none at fault. No rate hike, great claim process. You need to get some rate shopping going on.